19.7 C
Kawartha Lakes
Wednesday, May 25, 2022
HomeNewsFamily violence a big problem locally and across the country

Family violence a big problem locally and across the country

Statistics on domestic violence in Canada are staggering according to a report done in 2016 by Canada’s Chief Public Health Officer.

The report found an average of 172 homicides are committed every year by a family member. For approximately 85,000 victims of violent crimes, the person responsible for the crime was a family member and just under 9 million, or about one-in-three, Canadians said they had experienced abuse before the age of 15.

Almost daily we get reports of family violence in Peterborough. On Wednesday Police charged two people.

On April 26, 2017 the accused, a 57-year-old man, and the victim, a woman in her 50’s, became involved in an argument at their Peterborough home. It was reported that During the argument the accused threatened the victim and another family member and damaged the victim’s vehicle. While police were investigating they say the learned of another assault that happened in 2010. 

As a result of the investigation the accused was located at a Peterborough address where he was arrested and charged with domestic assault, uttering threats to cause death or bodily harm X2 and mischief under $5,000.

 Later Wednesday night police charged a man with assault with a weapon following a domestic dispute.

A 38-year-old man, and the victim, a woman in her 40’s, were at their Peterborough residence when they became involved in an argument according to police. 

 During the argument it was reported that the victim was struck with a weapon (TV remote). The incident was reported to police and officers attended the home. 

On Tuesday police charged two people with similar offences.

On April 23, 2017 police were sent to a Peterborough residence for a domestic dispute. It was reported that during the argument the 21-year-old male accused assaulted the victim, a woman in her teens, and also assaulted the victim’s father. The 21 year old male was charged

That same day another 21 year old Peterborough man was charged with assault on his 20 year old sister after an incident.

On Monday April 24th a 42-year-old man was charged after police say he assaulted his 30 year old girlfriend and a child in their home.

These are the charges from the last FOUR days only. Many of those charged will end up with no criminal record even if convicted.

In 2015/2016 almost 10,000 people in Ontario who were convicted of assaulting their partner possibly came out of it with no criminal record after taking the Partner Assault Response (PAR)classes.  The government is now reviewing the program.

In Peterborough more than 400 people who assaulted their partner have gone through PAR since 2014, and many of them would have received a conditional or absolute discharge after completion of the program. That means essentially, it’s like it never happened. The numbers for Kawartha Lakes were not available.

The John Howard Society is the PAR program service Provider for the City of Peterborough and Kawartha Lakes. The Ministry of the Attorney General (MAG)oversee’s the program. It is mandated by the courts and provides group education/counselling that is supposed to help participants stop their violent, abusive and controlling behaviour. It also provides outreach, safety planning, support, and referrals to community resources for the victims involved, according to the Ministry. “In general, upon successful completion of the PAR program as part of Early Intervention, cases may be resolved through a number of dispositions including a conditional discharge and probation, an absolute discharge or a s. 810 peace bond.” Emilie Smith, a spokesperson for the Ministry told Kawartha 411.

An absolute discharge is the lowest-level adult sentence that an offender can get. If an offender gets an absolute discharge, a finding of guilt is made but no conviction is registered, and they are not given any conditions to follow (i.e. a probation order ). It also will automatically purged from the CPIC database after one year and will only show as a non-conviction on a police check for a one year period.

A conditional discharge is similar to an absolute discharge because a finding of guilt is made,  no conviction is registered. What makes it different from an absolute discharge is that there are conditions that the offender must follow. The conditions always come in a probation order that can be in effect from one to three years. After that the record is wiped clean.

Is the program actually working? We don’t know exactly how many offenders received a conditional discharge versus an absolute discharge because the Ministry says it does not keep track of those statistics. We also don’t know how effective the program is because the Ministry hasn’t been keeping track of those statistics either. “Court records do not track cases specific to domestic abuse, as there is no Criminal Code charge or “offence type” specific to domestic abuse. The ministry tracks criminal court cases according to the specific Criminal Code offence.  As a result, we are unable to provide statistics specific to domestic violence/gender based violence.”  the Ministry told Kawartha 411.

Lynn Zimmer, Executive Director of the Peterborough YWCA says “if we are spending money on these programs and we don’t know if they are successful, is the money well spent or would the money be better spent somewhere else?

The Ministry says it is trying to gather the numbers. “We have launched a three-year in house study to determine the number of individuals who re-offend after completing the PAR program. Ministry staff are looking at recidivism rates and differences, if any, based on gender, age group, program completion status and court order type.” And they say they will be seeking input from service providers.

Sources say the Ministry is looking at the effectiveness of the program after some of the agencies that provide the program, complained.  Here’s how the Ministry describes it. “In 2014, the Ministry made changes to the PAR program to increase program capacity. This means offenders waiting for services can enter the program sooner and victims will have earlier access to support services offered by the PAR program. Some stakeholders expressed concerns with the program changes, and the ministry is working with PAR providers to address their concerns and to discuss their ideas for improvement.” Our mutual goal is to strengthen the PAR program so it is effective and sustainable.”

The program was reduced from 16 sessions to 12 mandatory sessions. Concerns were also expressed about the ministry revising service providers’ allocations to more closely reflect the current service demands in each jurisdiction according to Smith.  

Zimmer says “if there is no research about a reliable way going forward, it’s not a good thing”

Dana Hitherton is the Program coordinator for the John Howard Society in Peterborough. She’s also on the Provincial PAR Advisory Committee. She says “Our agency is committed to working with the Ministry to inform them of regional issues, which include both challenges and successes.  As with any social issue, DV (domestic violence) is complex, so any comments about effectiveness (of the PAR Program)would be anecdotal in nature.”

The program needs more money according to Zimmer. “To have an effective program it’s going to take an investment. It (currently) has humble funding and its a grassroots organization struggling to keep going, it’s not going to be improved without an investment”

But she likes the idea of a diversion program saying ” Jails aren’t good for changing violent behaviour”  And according to Zimmer some partners don’t want to see their children’s father/mother in jail.

Some wonder what type of message this sends to victims.

The ministry will be launching client surveys shortly to measure if the PAR program is achieving its objectives. The results may help to guide future program improvements.

hoto credit: -Jeffrey- Never Acceptable. Never Again. via photopin (license)




Don't forget to sign up for our morning newsletter.

Catch up on all the local news while enjoying your coffee.

Pamela Vanmeerhttps://www.kawartha411.ca/
Pamela VanMeer is a two time winner of the prestigious Radio Television Digital News Association (RTDNA) Award. Her investigative reports on abuse in Long Term Care Homes garnered international attention for the issue and won the Ron Laidlaw Award. She is a former reporter and anchor at CHEX News, now Global Peterborough and helped launch the New CHEX Daily, a daily half hour talk show. While at CHCH News in Hamilton she covered some of the biggest news stories of the day.

Most Popular