Recent reports on violence against staff in hospitals across Canada show they can be a dangerous place for employees and locally it’s no different.
Numbers obtained by Kawartha 411 show staff at Peterborough Regional Health Centre (PRHC)and Lindsay’s Ross Memorial Hospital (RMH)are experiencing increasing levels of violence every year.
Reported violent incidents against staff at PRHC have almost trippled since 2014. In that year there were 92 reported actual, attempted and threatened incidents of violence against staff. In 2015 the number rose to 139 and 255 in 2016. The hospital says the majority of reported incidents take place within the Geriatric Assessment and Behavioural Unit and in the Mental Health & Addictions program according to the hospital.
In 2015/16, RMH tracked a total of 183 Code White or Silent Code White (violent or potentially violent) incidents. These took place in the Emergency Department, Continuing Care Unit, Mental Health Unit, Intensive Care Unit and on the Medical and Surgical Units according to numbers obtained from the hospital. This year (2016/17) the final numbers aren’t in yet but as of December, 172 violent incidents had been reported with three months still remaining in the fiscal year. Kim Coulter Coordinator of Employee and Community Relations at RMH says “We are seeing an increase in violent incidents at RMH and the vast majority falls into the patient/client category.”
“Across Canada, incidents of workplace violence against health care workers happen daily. From verbal abuse to aggravated assault and sexual violence, rates are spiking in all health care settings from hospitals, emergency response, and home and long-term care.” Says Stella Yeadon, Communications CUPE, the union representing healthcare workers.
Hospital emergency departments and psychiatric wards are the most violent, according to research. Studies show those most at risk are nurses and personal support workers who have the most direct contact with patients and their families. CUPE says all the Ontario Registered Practical Nurses and Personal Support Workers in attendance at a CUPE health care conference recently specifically focused on violence, said they have experienced workplace violence.
PRHC implemented a new, centralized electronic reporting/management system in October 2013 and officials say that could partially contribute to the increase in the numbers. “This is partly due to the fact that the hospital’s new incident reporting system makes it more convenient for staff to make these reports. Enhanced education and training has also contributed to increased usage of the new reporting system over time” says Micheline Ough, Communications Lead at PRHC. These results are monitored closely by the Hospital’s senior administration team.
Through focus groups with health care staff who had experienced violence both directly as a target or as a witness to violence against a co-worker, CUPE’s Ontario Council of Hospital Unions working with independent researchers are going to be telling “first-person” accounts of workplace violence through both a video and soon-to-be published report. Ontario-wide media conferences are planned throughout 2017, which “give voice to the many health care workers who have been assaulted at work and challenge directly the culture of reprisal and attempts to silence workers who speak out against workplace violence,” says Michael Hurley, president of CUPE’s Ontario Council of Hospital Unions.
On May 8th NDP MPP France Gélinas introduced a motion in the Ontario Legislature asking the federal government to amend the Criminal Code of Canada to make violence against healthcare staff a more serious offence saying “That in the opinion of this House, members recognize violence against nurses and all front-line health care workers in hospitals, long term care homes and throughout Ontario’s healthcare system is unacceptable and urge the Federal Government to amend the Criminal Code to make it a more serious offence to assault a health care worker.”
PRHC’s education and training programs are an important part of their violence prevention program. Patients and visitors who exhibit violent behaviours are flagged electronically to notify staff who may care for or have contact with these individuals while they are in the hospital.
PRHC says general employee education and training includes (at orientation + annual refreshers):
- Code White (violent patient behaviour)
- Code Purple (hostage-taking)
- Code 99 (lockdown procedure, establishment of safe rooms; used in the event of a weapon)
- Violence Prevention Education/Training (Safe Management Group)
- Acting Out Behaviours Education/Training
Specialized employee training includes:
- Gentle Persuasive Approach
- PIECES and Montessori for dementia
- Least Restraint/Last Resort Policy/Training (working group; annual training for nurses)
“Signage is posted throughout the hospital to remind staff, patients and visitors that respectful and courteous behaviour is expected, and that aggressive behaviour will not be tolerated” says Ough.
Seven new violence prevention trainers have been trained and certified at PRHC in 2017. These front-line employee volunteers have earned special certification that qualifies them to train other staff in violence prevention according to the hospital.
The hospital notes it has also increased its Security team, and additional patrols have been added to increase the presence of Security throughout the building. The Security team is specially trained to address a variety of potentially violent situations within the hospital setting, which includes de-escalation methods. Four security guards received awards from the Peterborough Police Service in 2016.
Areas of the hospital that have a higher incidence of patient violence against staff (e.g. Mental Health & Addictions program; Geriatric Assessment & Behavioural Unit) have specific measures in place to support staff in working safely with these patients.
“PRHC continues to work with our partners to ensure a coordinated approach to safe patient care at the community level, which includes initiatives like the naloxone distribution program (in partnership with Peterborough Police Service, Peterborough Public Health and other community partners).” comments Ough.
RMH has installed glass enclosed work stations in the Emergency Department triage area, Mental Health nursing station, and the Cashier’s Office. Personal alarms are provided for staff working in high-risk areas and access to the Hospital is limited between 9pm and 6am. Anyone accessing the Hospital must enter through the Emergency Department where security approves access to the inpatient floors. There is a security presence 24/7 with extra night security in the Emergency Department.
The RMH’s violence prevention program also included Code White, Code Purple, Non-violent Crisis Intervention, Gentle Persuasive Approach and PIECES. They also have policies around working alone and Paid Duty Officers. Coulter says safety is embedded into their culture with special programs in high risk areas. “Along with ongoing training, safety measures include patient behaviour assessments, signage to alert staff to patients who show aggressive behaviour, posters alerting patients and visitors to the Hospital’s zero tolerance policy for violence, and communication tools for respectful conflict resolution.”
All employees also receive orientation which includes training for violence prevention and personal protection according to Coulter.

