Home News Lindsay Judge Rules Court Cannot Force Child To Be Vaccinated

Lindsay Judge Rules Court Cannot Force Child To Be Vaccinated

photo credit: Patrick Feller Jefferson County Courthouse, Beaumont, Texas 1805311219 via photopin (license)

KAWARTHA LAKES-A judge in Lindsay has ruled the court cannot force a child to be vaccinated.

In February a father brought a motion seeking an order directing that the mother ensure that their daughter is vaccinated against COVID-19 and that she receive any further and additional scheduled vaccinations in accordance with provincial recommendations. Local lawyer Wylita Clark represented the mother and Jarret Johnston the father.

According to the decision published earlier this month, the parties married in 2010 and separated in 2016. They have a 12-year-old daughter. The mother is not against the COVID-19 vaccine but said she was not prepared to force her daughter to be vaccinated against her will. The daughter had expressed verbally and in writing that she did not want the vaccine

According to the decision, in a two-page note dated January 5, 2022, the girl states she does not want to receive her COVID-19 vaccine as it has had negative effects on children. “She says she is mature enough to make her own decision and her mother has asked her countless times if she wanted the vaccine or if she has changed her views. She says she has read many articles “based on” the effects of the vaccine on children. She states, “If you still deem me as ‘not mature enough’ you should be able to tell my level of maturity by how I write. This is me talking, not my mother. This is my final decision. I do not want the vaccine. I hope my wishes will be respected.”

In response to a request by father for an opinion, the girl’s family doctor provided a note dated December 6, 2022, addressed “To whom it may concern”, stating: “This note will serve to confirm that it is highly suggested that [S.] be vaccinated with the Covid-19 vaccination. She has no known contraindications for the vaccine.”

In his ruling Justice Corkery cites Justice Pazaratz J. with respect to the court taking judicial notice of government information. In a recent case, similar to this case, he makes several critical observations:

“Why should we be so reluctant to take judicial notice that the government is always right?

a. Did the Motherisk inquiry teach us nothing about blind deference to “experts”? Thousands of child protection cases were tainted – and lives potentially ruined – because year after year courts routinely accepted and acted upon substance abuse testing which turned out to be incompetent.

b. What about the Residential School system? For decades the government assured us that taking Indigenous children away – and being wilfully blind to their abuse – was the right thing to do. We’re still finding children’s bodies.

c. How about sterilizing Eskimo women? The same thing. The government knew best.

d. Japanese and Chinese internment camps during World War Two? The government told us it was an emergency and had to be done. Emergencies can be used by governments to justify a lot of things that later turn out to be wrong.

e. Few people remember Thalidomide. It was an experimental drug approved by Canada and countries throughout the world in the late 1950’s. It was supposed to treat cancer and some skin conditions. Instead it caused thousands of birth defects and dead babies before it was withdrawn from the market. But for a period of time government experts said it was perfectly safe.

f. On social issues the government has fared no better. For more than a century, courts took judicial notice of the fact that it was ridiculous to think two people of the same sex could get married. At any given moment, how many active complaints are before the courts across the Country, alleging government breaches of Charter Rights? These are vitally important debates which need to be fully canvassed.

g. The list of grievous government mistakes and miscalculations is both endless and notorious. Catching and correcting those mistakes is one of the most important functions of an independent judiciary.

h. And throughout history, the people who held government to account have always been regarded as heroes – not subversives.

i. When our government serially pays out billions of dollars to apologize for unthinkable historic violations of human rights and security – how can we possibly presume that today’s government “experts” are infallible?

j. Nobody is infallible.

k. And nobody who controls other people’s lives – children’s lives – should be beyond scrutiny, or impervious to review.”

Justice Corkery goes on to say “the science relating to COVID-19 is developing.

“The “facts” are changing. As well, how can you take judicial notice of a moving target?”

“I am not prepared to take judicial notice of any government information with respect to COVID-19 or the COVID-19 vaccines.” states Corkery “Even if I were to take judicial notice of the “safety” and “efficacy” of the vaccine, I still have no basis for assessing what that means for this child. I must still determine how safe, how efficacious the vaccine is for this child. Does safe mean there are no side effects?  Is the vaccine effective in protecting her from contracting COVID-19, from spreading it, from dying from it, from severity of symptoms? As with informed consent, there are many factors that must be carefully considered in weighing risks and benefits. The facts about COVID-19 and the vaccines that our courts have taken judicial notice of are facts that lie at the dispositive end of the spectrum where it is most pressing to meet the criteria of notoriety or immediate demonstrability (R. v. J.M.). I cannot find that these scientific facts are notorious or that the government is a source of indisputable accuracy.”

Subsequently, the judge found the girl mature enough to make her own decisions regarding her health.

“Finally, I am satisfied that S. is a “mature minor” as explained by Abella J. in A.C. v. Manitoba (Director of Child and Family Services), 2009 SCC 30 at para 47. S. is capable with respect to treatment pursuant to s. 4 of the Health Care Consent Act, 1996, SO 1996, c 2, Sch A. She is mature enough to accept or refuse treatment. It is not in S’s best interest that the 2017 order be varied to add a condition that her mother ensure that she is vaccinated.”

Here is a link to the full decision: https://www.canlii.org/en/on/onsc/doc/2022/2022onsc4580/2022onsc4580.html?resultIndex=1

Kawartha 411
Exit mobile version