Home News Councillors clash over cash in lieu of parking issue

Councillors clash over cash in lieu of parking issue

KAWARTHA LAKES- ” I am sick and tired of people phoning me and emailing me saying that the city is hard to deal with.” Mayor Letham exclaimed. “This is a perfect example”

Councillors were trying to come to a consensus on a cash in lieu of parking proposal by APG Kent Investments. Staff proposed the group pay $76,300 for a shortage of 100 parking spaces.  Councillor Dunn had brought forth a motion asking his colleagues to take more time to look into the issue and determine a ‘fair price” for the spots. “This came on us fairly quickly, I got some calls from the BIA.” Dunn said of the staff report council received on the issue. “I have an issue with the cost.” Dunn says he’s been told parking spaces are currently worth about $4000 a spot and yet the proposal calls for the developers to pay approximately $700.

“These guys are willing to come and, not just them other people, spend millions of dollars in our community and we’re  talking about how we are going to pay for a parking garage?” the Mayor said. “We shouldn’t be asking them to pay for a parking garage, they are paying hundreds of thousands of dollars in DC’s (development charges) parking garages are 90% funded by DC’s.”

The group is looking at replacing much of the Grand Hotel on Kent Street with a $15 million, three story retail/restaurant and office building in it’s place. Under today’s guidelines that would require 167 parking spaces. The Grand currently has 67 and there isn’t room for more according to developers. “I can’t even believe that we are having this conversation right now.,” Mayor Letham continued. “We have a parking problem , we made a commitment as council to deal with it but don’t scare off a potential investors in our community until we get to that point.”

Councillor Stauble took issue with the Mayors comments seemingly blaming council for development delays. “I find your comments deeply offensive.” she said after the Mayor’s tirade. “If we want to attract residents to downtown Lindsay I think its worth a second thought and I support Councillor Dunn’s resolution.” Councillor Dunn also took issue with the Mayors comments. “We just got the information on Thursday or Friday, don’t you dare blame these people (council)for the fact that we aren’t getting leadership.”  Dunn said. “It was you that cast dispersion on this council”

Councillor James said he found the staff report on the issue inadequate and confusing. “This report creates more questions than answers. We don’t know the costs of a parking space in our downtown and thats alarming.”

The Mayor replied ” I resent your comments and I’m calling you out of order on that.”

Councillor Stauble says the deal would make the parking problem worse. “We just got a report saying we are at 100% (parking) capacity in the middle of the day. I did the math on this and I don’t understand why we would be reducing it by this.”

According to Mayor Letham the removal of parking meters is the real cause of the parking problems downtown. “You know why we have a parking problem in downtown Lindsay, because we took the parking meters out.” Letham commented. “We didn’t have a problem before that.”

“Do you really think in a couple years the city has grown to the point where there’s no parking. We’ve made a commitment to do a proper parking study so why don’t we let that roll out. In the mean time why don’t we endorse these folks with the previous formula we have.” Letham said

The previous formula he’s referring to is the one used for the Rexall on Kent St. During a redevelopment in 2007 a calculation was established that recommended a value of almost $1,400 per parking space.

Councillor Junkin was concerned about the staff in the new offices taking up spots for the entire day. ” I agree with Councillor Dunn, one of the problems I have is all these restaurants and staff reducing the number of parking spaces by 100 that doesn’t even accommodate the staff in the offices.”

Juan Rojas, Director of Engineering, informed council that a 2011 parking study found Lindsay has a deficit of 264 parking spots.

One of the developers on the project spoke out saying they had already spent four years on this project and wanted to move forward. “We’ve spent two years just with the historical society ,now two years with parking, this is four years, come on…”

Councillor Pollard felt the issue of a lack of parking should be separated from the development. “We’ve got two issue we are mixing together, the first one is do we want this development to go forward, how are we going to solve this parking problem?” Pollard remarked. “I think this should go ahead and then we need to make a serious decision about what to do about parking.”

The motion by Councillor Dunn failed and the cash in lieu deal passed.

Kawartha 411
Exit mobile version